Study: Steam Doesn't Help Croup

Lynn's picture
Submitted by Lynn on Wed, 07/19/2006 - 8:47pm.

Well, NOW what are we supposed to do?

Contrary to popular belief, humid air does not relieve the coughing and wheezing of croup in children, a new study shows.

"Typically, you get people to run a hot bath or shower in the bathroom. Or you get them to boil a kettle in the room, or have hot water in the corner of the room. That's the kind of first-aid advice that is often given at the point of first contact with a health-care professional," lead reviewer Dr. Michael Moore, a family doctor at Three Swans Surgery in Salisbury, England, said in a prepared statement.

In the study, published in the current issue of The Cochrane Library, Moore and his colleagues analyzed data from three studies of 135 children with croup who were seen in a hospital emergency department.

The outcomes for children treated with moist air did not differ significantly from those who received no treatment, the researchers found.

This runs counter to everything I've experienced about congestion in my children, though admittedly I have no experience with croup. You?

Technorati Tags:

( categories: )

Anhata's picture

None with croup, specifically, no

Submitted by Anhata on Wed, 07/19/2006 - 11:04pm.

But I'm taking this study with a grain of salt.

"We haven't shown any benefit from using the moisturized air in the emergency department, and there's no particular reason to think that it would work better at home," Moore said."

Cases of croup that end up in the hospital could so severe they may be past the point of aleviating symptoms with steam.

I dunno. Croup is specifically a viral throat thing--dry hacking/barking cough, it isn't really a congestion issue is it? I've always used steam for upper respitory issues.

Anhata
www.familynaturally.com
Your Family's General Store, Naturally

flamingomom's picture

Children's health

Submitted by flamingomom on Thu, 07/20/2006 - 7:27am.

In the hospital we used cool mist. That is why we used to get a lot of children that would take the car ride "cure". Their parents would panic, put them in the car and take them to the ER. The ride out in the cool damp night air would frequently help.
I can't imagine that warm moist air would help swollen airways all that much.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options