Raising Cain: Protecting the Emotional Life of Boys

Arugula's picture
Submitted by Arugula on Sun, 04/16/2006 - 7:54am.

I just started reading this book, I mean literally just started (I think I am on page 9) and already I really want to talk with someone about it. As the mother of two boys, I spend a lot of time trying to understand them, trying to figure out how to be a parent to them. It's odd, I have 8 younger brothers (6 adopted) but somehow I don't think I ever really figured out how to nurture the emotional life of a boy. Being candid about your body, no problem, but being candid about your feelings is a whole other problem.

The thing is, we were raised by parents who didn't display a whole lot of feelings. Don't get me wrong, my mother was very nurturing and she liked to smile but the only emotions she seemed to display were love/happiness and anger. My father was a person who liked to bottle his feelings. He rarely showed any strong feeling at all-occasional frustration/anger when fighting with my mom, occasional laughter at a movie, but other than that he was just the way he always is. I came away with a strong desire to not have feelings, feelings are a weakness someone can use against you.

My husband is by far the more emotionally healthy of the two of us. He has great volumes of love and joy, he shows frustration and anger (though he does that rarely), he can be anxious, excited, (sigh, I can't even name very many emotions, that really is quite sad). And so I run into a dilemma. I do not think my boys being emotionally stunted will be the result of their father, I think I will be the cause. And we are fighting a losing battle in that regard, their father works long hours and they are home with me all the time.

When Tain, my oldest son, was born, I felt he healed me in so many ways. He made me a better person. Then he turned two. He became aggressive and obstinate and impossible to please. This lasted until he was three and a half. I would lament that he was not naturally empathetic, I wondered how you taught a thing like empathy. He was, and still is, a child where words don't come easy. For most children, you say something is beautiful and over time they associate beauty with that word. For Tain, I found myself trying to describe what "beautiful" meant. So we tend to stick to concrete words, words like floor and car and leaf. He would get upset if I tried to tell him he was angry when he was. How do you teach emotional language to a child who has extreme difficulty understanding that which he cannot see? How do you teach emotional language to a child that argues with you whenever you try to put a label on a feeling?

Tain is four now, and a very pleasant person to have around. I think my favorite thing is his ability to compromise, if he wants something his brother has, he will try a trade and if that doesn't work, he will ask me to set a timer so they can take turns. I am really proud of him and he loves to hear me say that. He stifles his tears. I tell him it is okay to cry but I must have really taught him that it wasn't (he did go through a stage where he cried about everything. LOUDLY) because now, even when I tell him it is okay, he just sniffles and then swallows it down. And I feel a huge burden of guilt. Is it already too late? I know I carry around the remnants of the stage before. I am quick to get frustrated with him, I don't have the patience I should. I wonder if I am losing my taste for parenting and my children are suffering the consequence.

Rowan is 22 months old. He has always been more emotionally intuitive. He is very verbal. But he isn't as easy to parent. I worry about Tain because I don't want him to grow up like me emotionally and he and I are so alike. I worry about Ro because he is an enigma. He is so much like his father, but without his father's command of language. I don't understand what makes him tick, he cries easily, he gets his feelings hurt easily. Tain responds to scolding with anger, Rowan responds with tears. I think both feel the same way, though, and I feel that I need to not let little things get to me. So I wonder if I, like the boys in the book, have a giant well of anger that needs to be addressed. After all, girls may technically be more emotionally developed (according to the book) but it still isn't okay to be angry and resentful if you are a girl.

I really believe that the issues I face are not gender specific. I believe I would be in the same exact place if I had daughters instead of sons. We are not a family that suffers from cultural stereotypes. My mother was an amazingly strong woman, a force to be reckoned with, the leader of our family. My husband's family was more traditional but his mother is a person who gets things done, she is the emotional conduit of the family a person of big feelings: big laughs, big tears. I really don't like crying. I don't like doing it and I don't like having it done at me (isn't that aweful? But it is how I feel, that someone is crying AT me, expecting me to take those feelings, do God-knows-what with them, and make them feel better. And that makes me angry and irritated). Obviously I need some sort of professional help with this. If you know what your problem is, why is it so hard to change it?

Technorati Tags:

( categories: )

Arugula's picture

Just thinking as I reread

Submitted by Arugula on Sun, 04/16/2006 - 7:56am.

Just thinking as I reread this that maybe it isn't that my parents displayed few feelings, maybe I (like Tain) didn't know how to interpret them so I put them in two categories: good (happy) and bad (sad/angry/frustrated). How did I end up so stunted?

Hippie Homemaker's picture

What I'm getting out of your

Submitted by Hippie Homemaker on Sun, 04/16/2006 - 11:32am.

What I'm getting out of your post is that you are beating yourself up for the person you are, and have been all your life. Don't! You are who you are. We all have parts of our personality that we don't like, and we should always strive to improve upon ourselves, but don't put yourself into a box of "perfection" and then beat yourself up because it's impossible to live up to it.

Everyone is different, and I think that's wonderful, as long as it's not in an extreme sense such as a tendency to do harm to others. Being different is what makes each of us special, makes us unique like a snowflake. Each snowflake that falls is different in some small way, as we are.

Know your faults and work on improving them, but don't think you're a bad person just because you're not as emotional as someone else. Being emotional carries it's own problems, such as always thinking everyone is out to hurt you and doesn't love you.

The overly emotional person needs to work on their personality just as the person who doesn't show much emotion. All types of people need to try to create a balance and moderation, but it's not so important that we cause ourselves to end up with low self esteem, thinking we're not "normal". We are ALL normal, whatever normal is.

As far as your children...I've got three sons, all grown and married. They are all different in their personalities, and they all grew up to be fine young men. I know I made a lot of mistakes raising them, because I am not a perfect human being, just as no parent is. We just do the best we can.

I think the most important thing we can try to teach our children is to respect others and try not to bring harm to them. To treat others as they would want to be treated, kind of like putting the other person's shoes on to see where they're coming from.

One of my sons was very difficult to raise from the time he started interacting with us and others. He was overly sensitive and got angry or hurt if one of us said anything to him. To him, everything was an assult and we were out to get him. He thought we didn't love him if we tried to correct him in any way, and no amount of telling him different changed his mind. He held grudges for days.

He wanted to learn to play ball like his other brother, but it was impossible to teach him because if my husband tried to show him how to do something he took it as a personal insult and would run into the house mad at the world.

After dealing with him for so many years, we lost our wits a few times and took his bait, agruing with him. It just turned into a shouting match and made things worse. I even told him one time he was like Nellie Olsen on "Little House", always thinking we didn't love him, always running to his room and sulking. He told me after he was grown that it still hurt to remember us calling him "names" and putting him down. And I can remember telling him he was bull-headed, stubborn, willful, acting silly, etc. It was all true, but if I had it to do over again, I wouldn't make him feel even worse by saying things like that to him. He was having a hard enough time dealing with his emotions as it was. I would just let him be "him" and go on about my business and wait until he calmed down to reassure him that we did love him, and that he needed to try to not take everything we did or said so personally.

I have the bad habit of reacting with my own anger when someone else shows anger. It's like a snowball effect with me. And he had a lot of anger in him. But don't get me wrong, you can't let your child go around slamming doors off their hinges, or throwing things. You have to put your foot down when it comes to that. But if it's just an inner battle they're displaying, getting angry and running to their room, I think you need to just let them calm down and then try to talk to them, without personal insults and reassure them that you do indeed love them and hope they realize it one day.

With children like that, there is an inner battle going on inside them that they are projecting onto other people and blaming them for what they are feeling. They're having an even harder time making it to adulthood than the average child. I don't know why they have their inner demons, or the perfect way to handle it, except just reassure them as many times as they need it and not allow it to wear you down.

Another thing I would be sure to do would be to verbally praise them more. Not just give them negative attention when they were doing something wrong, but pay attention when they did something good and praise them for it. Give them a hug and kiss for it and tell them what a good thing they did or said. I did do that, but not often enough. Life is a harried race when you're raising children and you have your hands full trying to get everything done yesterday, and you tend to not stop often enough to give a hug and a word of praise.

We must have done something right, because now he's one of my best friends. He calls almost everyday and we talk like two pals. We always tell each other we love the other one before we hang up, just as we do with all of them. And the greatest thing is he believes us!

Just like my other two, he's grown into a fine human being and who everyone tells us is the nicest, most courteous young man they've ever met. He does still have problems with getting nervous and is on medication for that, and it is working wonders in keeping him balanced.

So don't lose heart if you think you have a problem child. Just continue to treat them with love and try to instill kindness into them. Don't think none of it is sinking in. It may take years before you see your teachings had an effect, but one day you will see it!

I'm not trying to come off like an expert on child-rearing. I'm just speaking from the experience of raising a difficult child. And please don't take too much stock in all the books out there written by so-called experts. Have more confidence in yourself and get rid of that guilt you're packing. Guilt is never good for anything but tearing you apart and making you miserable.

Stop worrying about things from your past and concentrate on now. The things in our past we can do nothing about. I said earlier if I could go back I'd change some things, but who wouldn't? I only know that it turned out alright anyway.

You're going to have many more trials ahead in raising your children, and you're going to do just fine. Just love them, teach them right from wrong, let them know you'll always be there for them, send the guilt packing, and you'll do just as good a job of parenting as anyone else has done.

Sorry for this long comment...I tend to get a little windy once I get started!
Rachel

Hippie Homemaker's picture

By The Way

Submitted by Hippie Homemaker on Sun, 04/16/2006 - 3:33pm.

Welcome! I just noticed that you are as new here as I am.

Rachel

Anhata's picture

Keep reading that book, and don't take parenting personally

Submitted by Anhata on Fri, 04/21/2006 - 1:47am.

Seriously, one of the hardest lessons I've had to learn, and I'm still trying to get a grip on it, is that my kid's tantrums, emotionalism, acting up, whatever, honestly has very little to do with me and everything to do with them. You can't take it personally.

It seems like it's all about you and your parenting, but most times, it's all about them.

That seems counterintuitive? I've had the opportunity to observe some aMAZing moms at work with their kids in the middle of a "moment". The thing that impressed me the most was when a mom DIDN'T take the temper tantrum personally, as I would have done, but totally kept her focus on the moment and what the child was saying to her. Totally listening to what the child was saying and letting the obstinancy the kid was throwing up slide right on by.

If two people are being obstinant, even if one is a parent the other a child, the wall between them just gets thicker and thicker until nothing helpful can get through. In my family (growing up) that could easy escalate into something ugly. I sometimes think my life's work is to learn how to NOT take it personally.

Don't automatically assume that your children's challenging behavior is because of some lack in you, something you have or haven't done, or something that you're not doing right. If you don't feel like you're emotionally equipped to deal with challenging behaviors, by all means, look for help, but don't automatically go to "if I were only a better parent...". Tell yourself, often if you must, that You're Doing The Best You Can With The Information That You Have At This Time.

For boys I always recommend "The Wonder of Boys", Oh, and if you're open to it, read The Tao of Motherhood by Vimalia McLure. Very helpful in focusing on what's really important. "There is nothing more receptive and flowing than water, yet there is nothing better for polishing the stone. A mother's nature is paradox. Your strength is in your gentleness. Your authority is in receptivity. Your power is in letting go."

Anhata
www.familynaturally.com
Your Family's General Store, Naturally

Arugula's picture

I think what I take

Submitted by Arugula on Fri, 04/21/2006 - 6:38am.

I think what I take personally is my behavior in a situation. For instance, my son has a habit of telling me he loves me or wants a hug when I am in the middle of doing something. I know it is because his other ways of getting me to take a break aren't working (I do end up doing projects for hours straight so it isn't an every-fifteen-minutes thing) but he really does mean it, he is very sincere. I feel annoyed at the interruption and I act annoyed with him. So I teach him that telling someone you love them or wanting to snuggle them will often result in that person being irritated with you. I do believe we do the best with what we had at the time but I don't believe we should continue to be ignorant and use that phrase as a catch all. And if anyone thinks that the way we interact with our children doesn't shape who they are, they are living in a dream world. I don't really want to be excused, I want to be held accountable for my part of his life. There will be time enough when he is an adult to wash my hands of his decisions. At 4, however, I am still teaching him how to be a good person and young children learn best, not by words, but by actions and example. I really don't see why all replies to this are so adamantly about me just continuing on when I really want to change.

Becky's picture

perhaps your son has a point

Submitted by Becky on Fri, 04/21/2006 - 8:15am.

Not about your parenting, but about your personal health. Maybe you would be well-served by scheduling in more breaks, in general. Set a timer and take a little time out every hour to get a drink, give him a hug, stretch your legs, and focus your eyes on something else. My fifth-grade teacher told us that it is unhealthy to focus eyes at close range (or far range) for too long without a break.

Anhata's picture

I'm sorry my reply offended you

Submitted by Anhata on Fri, 04/21/2006 - 4:41pm.

It was meant to be supportive because it seemed that you were talking about guilt, here, which does not improve parenting. But I obviously misread what your concerns were. Apologies.

Anhata
www.familynaturally.com
Your Family's General Store, Naturally

Shaun's picture

Many styles of expression

Submitted by Shaun on Fri, 04/21/2006 - 6:57am.

Arugula (cute name!)

I think change is great, but I think maybe what the comments you're getting are reflecting is that no one ever really shames or whips herself into genuine personal change, and no one wants to see you down on yourself. Slowly but surely I have been learning not to trust that voice that says "try harder try harder," because for me that is not the voice of self-care or self-improvement, but the voice of shame from the past, telling me I'll never be good enough.

I think that "I'm screwing up feeling" is often the source of my "bad parenting behavior" -- for example, I yell or turn off because I am already feeling incompetent because the house is messy or my child is doing something that I should have taught them not to do (or vice versa), and so my disappointment in myself feeds the kind of response to my kids that I really would rather not do!

I think working on emotional intelligence is important for everyone and I applaud you for doing it. I just want to add one other thing on behalf of the introverts of the world -- like my and my family! I think this is such an extroverted world that we have come to associate typically extroverted expressions of emotion with openness and emotional health while calling introverted expressions of emotion (processing privately, sharing feelings selectively) withdrawn or closed. I am thinking of one man I know who constantly felt overwhelmed by his extroverted mother's desire to "share feelings," when thinking out loud and processing with another person was just not his way of dealing with feelings.

Excessive sharing can be unhealthy, just as excessive secretiveness or "stuffing" can be unhealthy. I guess I'm saying that as I've worked on emotional intelligence myself I've tried to honor my personal need for privacy as well as that of my family members, my need for quiet time to process, and the reality that the visible expressions of emotion don't have to match the intensity of the emotion inside.

So honor the ways you are unique and your own needs, whatever they are, as you seek to change!

Shaun
www.homeschoolblogger.com/shaunms

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options