New Weight Loss Surgery Still a Crappy Idea

Submitted by Lynn on Sun, 01/29/2006 - 1:21pm.

Hottest thing in European weight loss surgery: inserting a balloon into your stomach and filling it with saline.

Inserted down the patient's throat, a round silicon balloon is filled with a saline solution and remains in the stomach for about six months, when it is deflated and taken out before the material degrades.

"We introduce a balloon of half a liter volume (about a pint) in the stomach and inflate it so it takes up space and helps slow down the eating," said Dr. Nicola Basso, the obesity surgeon who performed the procedure on Campati in early January. "This causes a sense of fullness, and the patient is helped to lose weight."

The balloon, which also contains methylene blue to signal any leak, does not alter the shape of the abdomen and is too big to slip down into the digestive tract.

Basso, who has performed the procedure on about 700 patients in six years, said the technique allows an average drop of 33-44 pounds over six months, although the weight loss is often temporary.

"The efficacy of the treatment depends on how the patient is able to use these six months to change his dieting habits in a more or less stable way," Basso said.

Or, you know, you could just use those six months to NOT put a balloon down your stomach, change the way you eat and live, and deal with your underlying issues--things you have to do even if you put a balloon down your stomach.

If you MUST do something surgical, this looks to be a better, much less lethal intervention than gastric bypass surgery, which has a mortality rate of 1%--that means for every 100 people who have the surgery, one dies. But if you don't take responsibility for your life and health, it won't make a bit of difference; you'll regain at least some of the weight.

Here's an Idea: Change your lifestyle. It's nonsurgical and it's even free.

Listen, I've had a weight problem all my life, and an eating disorder. I've been on every diet known to mankind, I've done 12-step work around it, I've faced it all. My cardiologist even recommended gastric bypass surgery; I weighed 255 at the time, my weight had nothing to do with my heart attack , and I was losing weight. I dismissed it out of hand. Surgery is SO not a solution to the problem, and in fact I have lost 20 pounds since he suggested it, 40 overall--for once I'm looking forward to seeing him next month.

What it takes:

  • The courage to face your underlying issues. I'm still facing them, but I rarely turn to food any more. For me 12-step work and the work of Geneen Roth were crucial.
  • The willingness to figure out what nutrition works for you. This takes time and research. What works for one person will not work for another. What I have found works for me is eating later in the day and concentrating any grain- and sugar-type carbs to the last thing I eat in the day, if at all. I try not to snack. I don't do this perfectly, but that's my guideline.
  • The responsibility to do things we don't necessarily want to do, like exercise (bleh) and research on our own health issues. If I had left my health to the professionals I would be dead now, and that's not an exaggeration. I don't mean you should ignore your doctors; I mean you should do your due diligence and become the director of your health care. YOU ARE NOT HELPLESS. It is up to you.

There is no quick fix. There is no miracle cure. There is no pill, no operation, no doctor that can do it. There is only you, and time, and work. And that's not as scary as it sounds. It's the most hopeful thing I have ever realized.

Categories: , , , ,

Technorati Tags:
( categories: )

Guest's picture

Weight Loss Surgery

Submitted by Guest (not verified) on Wed, 08/22/2007 - 1:03pm.

There needs to be more of these type of articles...a woman I know who was NOT old and reasonably healthy other than carrying a few extra pounds (she came from a family of "big" people - meaning solid, tall and big boned...) decided to have this gastric band surgery and 4 weeks later she is dead. She lost a huge amount of weight in those few weeks which cannot have been pleasant, continued on with the process thinking she would come right. Note please: constant vomitting is NOT normal. Of course these surgeon's who carry out these procedures want to keep these fatal complications quiet and as you have stated in your article:1 in a 100 people DIE. My friend did not need this surgery and should have been turned down for the procedure, she just needed some small diet changes and regular exercise. It is also very unfortunate that a lot of these patients do not share with many that they are going to have this procedure done, just like any elective surgery it is usually kept a secret...

Guest's picture

The balloon weight loss

Submitted by Guest (not verified) on Wed, 09/26/2007 - 11:32pm.

The balloon weight loss system is NOT gastric bypass surgery. Study your subject before you go spouting comments about it. Further, the liquid filled balloon is rarely used these days. for many, many years good physicians have been using a smaller steril air filled balloon. this particular procedure is low risk, outpatient, takes less than an hour, lasts for nly 6 months, and can be reversed at any time. Not like your insipid level of knowledge of weight loss options. Finally, if people could control their food intake, they wouldn't need help losing weight. It must be nice to be perfect like you are, right? No extra pounds around your mid section, no excess weight? Considering that 64-67% of the world is overweight, you mean to say that in your family 2 out of 3 people are not overweight? Grow up.

Lynn's picture

Let me guess

Submitted by Lynn on Thu, 09/27/2007 - 9:50am.

You are either:

A) A bariatric surgeon;

B) The wife or mother of a bariatric surgeon;

or, my bet

C) Someone with a balloon down her stomach.

Did you actually read what I wrote? I have been fat all my life--and you know, I'm the only member of both my birth family and my own family who is overweight. Try carrying that around all your life. My weight has been a source of crushing pain to me since childhood. I've been reminded almost every day of my life that I am fat, that I am ugly, that I am worthy of scorn, that I am "other." You want pain? I got pain. GROW UP? Baby, look in the mirror. Stop feeling sorry for yourself and defensive.

I'm still fat. I work on it every day, as constructively as I can. My problem isn't eating too much, in fact some days I *forget* to eat. Earlier in my life, I *definitely* had an eating disorder; I overate constantly. I overcame that. Now, though, I have a slow metabolism and I have lived a sedentary life--and I'm facing the accumulated results of 30 years of living with an eating disorder. But I'm working on it. I always will be.

There's more to it than food. And no one is confusing bariatric balloons with gastric bypass. I was speaking to the larger issues.

If you don't deal with the underlying issues, you can put any number of sterile air-filled balloons down your throat and as soon as they pop the weight will come back. That's my point. For the risks these kinds of interventions entail, and the long-term results they offer, these interventions don't pan out.

If they did for you, I'm sincerely happy for you. SINCERELY. You are very lucky. And I hope you stay lucky.

Lynn Siprelle, Editor

Guest's picture

The balloon weight loss

Submitted by Guest (not verified) on Thu, 10/25/2007 - 7:22pm.

Okay right it isn't gastric bypass surgery - it is a stupid balloon they put in your stomach - excuse me for getting the terminology wrong! All I wanted to emphasize is that it is killing people - what a major complication - to lose one's LIFE!! This should only be done in absolute extreme obesity, I think the term is morbidly obese, not just to lose a few pounds to look "attractive" again - I use that term very loosely as I believe you can be attractive carrying extra weight. After my friend died, I did a lot of research on the net and could find very little that emphasized the dangers and this was one of the few sites that mentioned the high risk. Thankyou Lynn.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options