The Value of a SAHM?

Shaun's picture
Submitted by Shaun on Mon, 01/19/2004 - 1:23pm.

I saw the mother of one of Sophie's sunday school friends this weekend and she told me some awful news.

Apparently her husband of 22 years left her for his Internet girlfriend. They have 4 kids, from college age to 4 years old. He decided he needed to "start over."

This woman took care of the kids and the home, sewed *all* the kids clothes, and did all those things most of us know too well -- the cooking, the cleaning, the driving, the organizing, the supervising, the late nights, etc.

During the divorce and custody legal proceedings, as they attempted to work out child support, etc., this is what the enlightened judge told her:

"You've sponged off your husband long enough. It's time for you to go out and get a job."

Excuse me?!

Obviously she'll be getting a job -- they were a middle-class family, so no amount of alimony and child support could be enough to keep her from working.

But to be forced to tolerate that kind of humiliation from a judge during the already humiliating divorce proceedings stemming from an Internet romance?!

I've not seen this woman for several months, so I did not feel comfortable asking questions if she didn't offer the information, but doesn't she have some legal recourse for the judge's unprofessionalism?

And what do you think -- is this attitude still so prevalent that a judge would feel free to say that kind of thing in a public courtroom?

The lack of respect this woman has had to endure from two men who, by virtue of their positions, should have been seeking her best interests, is absolutely shocking!

Technorati Tags:

( categories: )

Trisa's picture

Thats is just so wrong! Spong

Submitted by Trisa on Mon, 01/19/2004 - 1:31pm.

Thats is just so wrong! Sponge off. Get real.
Nothing was said I guess about his affair.
Being a SAHM is a job. Yes some SAHM are NOT good mothers and maybe they are really lazy. But this was not the case. I work harder as a mom than I ever did before I had kids and worked outside of the home.
Its a job you never really get a break from. Most days a 15 hours a day job! he had NO right to say that to her.

Susannah's picture

I find this so infuriating.

Submitted by Susannah on Mon, 01/19/2004 - 5:46pm.

I can barely think how to respond to something like that. A man leaves his family, tears up his children's hearts, and then the abandoned wife gets abuse from the judge? WHAT KIND OF WORLD IS THIS? My heart breaks for this woman.

Kitty Mc's picture

From my time spent as a corre

Submitted by Kitty Mc on Mon, 01/19/2004 - 7:54pm.

From my time spent as a corrections officer, I can indeed confirm that many, many, many family court judges are utter assholes. There's just no other way to put it.

I don't know if they get burnt out, cynical, or what. And don't get me wrong, there are some great ones out there too. But the ones that survive the daily meat grinder of family court end up being the closest things to saints on this earth OR they turn out to be cynical SOBs who take out their jadedness on the people that come before them.

And you know, it's a heck or a lot easier to be a cynic than it is to be truly compassionate.

I wouldn't say that the judge's attitude is prevalent everywhere. But in any given courtroom, the judge's mood/temper/attitude/biases are frankly all that matters. And they don't have anything to lose by saying exactly what they feel in their courtroom. Even if they are 'elected', when was the last time you really paid any attention to who was running for your local court judge/researched their records, ect? Probably the same as everyone else. (That is, if they are running opposed in the first place!)

However, it might be good for her to get a copy of the court record, and then show it to the media. (If she can get them to care). But that won't help her settlement. I'm wondering where her lawyer was/is in all this.
-Kitty, mama to Fiona, Thomas, and Dylan.

Fern's picture

One more reason why we, as mo

Submitted by Fern on Mon, 01/19/2004 - 8:37pm.

One more reason why we, as moms, must encourage our children (especially daughters) to first become self sufficient in this old world before trusting their entire future to the whims of a spouse.

Woman #2 might not be so happy to have hubby dear if wife had cause to sue her for alienation of affection.

The Judges comment might be of interest to more than just the lady's local media. I can't imagine one making such a comment in a public forum unless a woman kept having children against her husbands wishes in order to get to stay home or something of that sort. Though I'm certainly not suggesting that is the case here. Sometimes people with a little bit of power (actually Judges have a whole lot of power)get so arrogant they forget that life has a way coming back to slap us in the face when we do people wrong.

elizabethanne's picture

That's just profoundly... dis

Submitted by elizabethanne on Mon, 01/19/2004 - 9:40pm.

That's just profoundly... disgusting. There's no other word for it.
My one guess (because I am, by nature, the one who stands in the middle - I sometimes think I missed my career as a mediator, because I am quick ot try and see both sides) is that he's used to seeing "Society Wives", who stay at home not out of a sense of duty or motherhood, but simply because they *can* and 'don't want to work' (or has been through a nasty divorce himself).

But still... the ideal is for a judge to set ASIDE such things, and take each case *on its own merits*. I hope she *does* make a stink out of this - this judge deserves to be tarred and feathered!!!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.
  • Web and e-mail addresses are automatically converted into links.
More information about formatting options