Ask the Miserly Mom: Shared Values and Easy-Bake Mix

Miserly Moms:
When you and your husband don't agree on staying home, and homemade toy oven cake mix
by Jonni McCoy
The Miserly Mom
Q:  I quit my teaching job this year leaving behind EXCELLENT health insurance, so that I could stay home with our now 11-month-old daughter. I take in three children for a total of $200-255/week.  My husband is a carpenter and earns approximately $400/week (no benefits). On the surface it seems as though we should be able to swing it easily, then I take a shocking look at our spending. Unfortunately my husband smokes, which is costing us nearly $300/month!!! I am not going to get him to quit, so that is a fixed expense. Our house payment is $500/month, and the car is $370/month. Once you take out those fixed expenses you end up with $1230/month.

Next comes one of our biggest problems, HEALTH INSURANCE!!! I couldn't believe it when our new, private, insurer told us that for $100/month we would have a $2500 deductible, NO maternity coverage, and a $500 prescription deductible!!!! So, basically we are only covered in absolute tragedies. 

I want more than anything to stay at home with my daughter until she is in school. But my husband is losing patience with always being short on money and really wants me to go back to work.

Thank you so much for the service you provide!
--Mom in Need

A: It sounds like your husband does not share the same values as you do, namely the need for your daughter to have you at home. This is your number one obstacle. Until he feels that this is a priority, he will not want to give up anything or change lifestyles to make it happen. So, I would first start gathering information on the importance of having a mom at home during a child's early years and discuss it with him.

The changes that you may need to explore to make this work will require some agreement on his part. When we first make the adjustment to one income living, we often have to do without the comforts and luxuries that we feel we deserve or have become accustomed to. First, you may need to consider selling the new car and getting a used or less expensive new car so that your payments are either lower or gone altogether. Second, you should look at reducing the spending in other areas as well, especially groceries. There are many ways to reduce that expense and use that money elsewhere. The first half of Miserly Moms is devoted to groceries.

The other thing to consider is whether it is your responsibility to provide for the family financially. I believe that this is your husband's job, and you are to care for the emotional and homemaking needs of your family. Your husband is choosing to live a certain way and expects you to make up the financial difference it causes. You need to decide if you want to take on that role.

As for health insurance, you have found a fairly good plan. Many families pay more than that for similar coverage. Private insurance is expensive. Stick with a plan and increase your coverage as you can afford it. Remember that you won't be in this situation forever. Things will get better.

*****

Q: My dear 8 year old daughter received an Easy Bake Oven for Christmas this year. I know that the mixes go for about $5 for a box of four mixes. Is there a cheaper substitute for these little mixes or could I use regular cake and cookies mixes?

Thanks so much.
--Tina

A: My daughter loves using her Easy Bake Oven but I agree with you; there has to be a cheaper way to make cakes and cookies than buy their mixes. So we have a collection of recipes for doing it ourselves. Below are a few to get you started. Happy baking!

White Frosting Mix
2 cups powdered sugar -- sifted
3 tablespoons instant nonfat milk powder
6 tablespoons vegetable shortening

In a medium bowl, combine powdered sugar and milk powder. Stir with a wire whisk to blend. With a pastry blender cut in shortening. Spoon about 1/3 cup of mixture into each of 8 small bags. Seal tightly.  Makes 8 packages. For chocolate frosting, add 1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa.

To use: Combine 1 package of the above mix plus 3/4 teaspoon water in a small bowl. Stir well with a spoon until smooth and creamy. Makes about 1/4 cup frosting. A drop or two of vanilla may be added if desired.

Brownies
2 1/2 T. sugar
1 t. oil
1/8 t. vanilla extract
4 t. chocolate syrup
2 1/2 T. flour

Sir together sugar, oil, vanilla, chocolate and flour until the batter is smooth. Pour batter into greased and floured pan. Bake 15 minutes.

Chocolate Cake
6 teaspoons flour
4 teaspoons sugar
1/4 teaspoon baking powder
1 teaspoon unsweetened cocoa
3/4 teaspoon shortening
1 pinch salt
6 teaspoons milk

Mix together the flour, sugar, baking powder, cocoa, shortening and salt. Add milk and stir until smooth. Pour into greased baking pan that comes with the toy oven. Bake for 12 to15 minutes. If you want white cake, omit the cocoa and add a drop or two of vanilla with the milk. Makes 1 serving.

Quick Cake
2 tablespoons commercial cake mix -- such as Jiffy
1 tablespoon water

Mix cake mix and water. Place in greased toy cake pan. Bake for 10 minutes. Makes 1 serving.



Jonni McCoy is author of "Miserly Moms: Living On One Income In A Two Income Economy" and "Frugal Families: Making The Most Of Your Hard Earned Money!" To submit a frugal question that you would like answered, write to miserlymoms@miserlymoms.com -- please put "Column Questions" in the subject field. And visit the Miserly Moms Website.

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Sarah N. 's picture

This is a crazy response. Look at the economic FACTS here!

Dear Ms. Mccoy,

What on earth are you not understanding about Mom in Need's situation? I have been in her shoes too and your response, in my opinion, does not at all address her key points, which I have lived myself and know too well how it feels to be in her shoes.

a) Her husband is spending almost as much on cigarettes as they're spending on car payments. This is unacceptable and it affects their health insurance rates as well!

b) His wife is bringing in an income! It is NOT a one-income family! She is a childcare provider! What part of that did you not understand?

c) His husband is spending more than she earns on cigarettes! Stop smoking, and they save $300 a month, she brings in $200-250 a month, then she is making more than he is.

d) He is not earning enough! $20k a year is barely a subsistence income in most parts of the country. He should get a better job or go back to school, instead of pressuring her to abandon her kids. She is doing a great job compromising already, by taking in children for extra income!

e) If she goes to work she will probably spend at least $100 a week on daycare. Maybe more, since this is a young toddler. If they have more kids it will be more money. It is not worth it!!! She has found a GREAT SOLUTION! HE JUST NEEDS TO QUIT SMOKING and GO BACK TO SCHOOL!

f) This guy sounds like a loser who is acting out his own feelings of inadequacy by pressuring his wife to be everything he's not. I tried everything, including being submissive and coy, catering to his ego, and doing everything he thought he wanted me to do. Nothing will make a man like this happy, trust me. He is depressed because he can't stop smoking and can't make a decent living to support his family and he's taking it out on his wife. PLAIN AND SIMPLE. What part of this do you not see?

g) Oh, and basically she is working her ass off watching kids... to pay for his tobacco habit. So he can get on her case to make more money. IS THAT RIGHT?

What part of these many economic and personal realities have eluded you here?

Sarah

Sara W's picture

I do agree that your answer

I do agree that your answer was a little unclear and not up-to-date with the current financial realities of some, possibly most families, but it's your prospective on the situation. I do agree that the majority of children would benefit wildly from having a loving mother or father at home. Some families are unable to stay home with their children simply because food and shelter are much more basic needs. Then there is the reality that some women really enjoy their work or are used to the working environment. Our culture is constructed of changes that are different from the ones before it, wonderful and/or dangerous, but culture's created by the choices people make in life... or and of course, marketing.

I think I disagree with Sarah that her husband should return to school. I mean, sure it's a great option, but it could be a detrimental one. Clearly, they cannot afford it, and in my opinion, a loan is not the solution.

There are many options; don't limit yourself to the obvious ones. You have to explore your memory, resources around you, people around you, and make a decision together. You have to face the uncomfortable conversation, the ones that could be harmful to your relationship, because if you don't, I'm afraid you might coast through life.

Anyway, it's not my situation or choice, but I hope you and your family are able to find a common ground and that things work out... however that may look. Smiling

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Smileys
:);):(:D}:):P:O:?8):jawdrop::sick::grin:
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Link to Amazon products with: [amazon product_id inline|full|thumbnail|datadescriptor]. Example: [amazon 1590597559 thumbnail] or [amazon 1590597559 author]. Details are on the Amazon module handbook page.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You may quote other posts using [quote] tags.
  • Textual smileys will be replaced with graphical ones.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.